- jhunter2
- Nov 29, 2024
- 6 min read

While watching the play-by-play of the “competitive” “chess match” between Colorado and Oklahoma State earlier this afternoon, it occurred to me that my first mock draft of the cycle hadn’t dropped yet, so here it is. In honor of the Christmas season and Matt Eberflus’ firing, I will be gifting you all with short and sweet breakdowns of each pick and why I made it.
NYG - QB Cam Ward, Miami
The idea of pairing a young Jameis Winston with Malik Nabers and Tyrone Tracy Jr. would be tantalizing to say the least, and Cam Ward, one of the nation’s top ball-throwers, can fill into that narrative seamlessly.
JAX - WR/CB Travis Hunter, Colorado
Arguably the best prospect in the draft regardless of position (of which he can play at least two), Travis Hunter can take over in Jacksonville as either Trevor Lawrence’s top target or Will Levis’s. Or both.
LV - QB Shedeur Sanders, Colorado
Shedeur Sanders is a talented quarterback prospect, but I personally wouldn’t spend a top-3 pick on him unless absolutely necessary. In this case (for a handful of reasons) it is necessary, as much as I might not enjoy it.
NE - OL Will Campbell, Louisiana State
I flirted heavily with the idea of Kelvin Banks Jr. here, but Will Campbell is just a better football player at this point in time.
CAR - CB Will Johnson, Michigan
Jaycee Horn needs help. With star DL Derrick Brown coming back from injury and Will Johnson in the fold, he’ll have some.
NYJ - DL Mason Graham, Michigan
With Texas legend Quinn Ewers (hook ‘em) likely falling into the second round due to injury and unwarranted public hate, the Jets can wait to address quarterback until later and swing big on an absolute monster on the defensive front to run alongside Quinnen Williams.
TEN - WR Tetairoa McMillan, Arizona
Will Levis is too generational of a talent to go to waste, and pairing him with a dominant ball-winner in McMillan should give Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes nightmares for years from getting run out of the stadium year after year in the playoffs.
CLE - OT Kelvin Banks Jr., Texas
One of the most intriguing prospects in the 2025 NFL Draft class, Kelvin Banks can step in really anywhere on the offensive line in Cleveland (especially at left tackle) and start fairly quickly.
CHI - EDGE/LB Abdul Carter, Penn State
Not really much question whether Chicago should take an edge-rusher here with the state of the draft board at this point, and any of the top 4 options (all of which will be gone by 20 in this mock) would make sense to me. Carter might not be Micah Parsons, but he could be.
NO - EDGE Mykel Williams, Georgia
I thought about Jalen Milroe here, but the Saints’ defensive front is just bad, and it has very little upside to build on. Williams might need some time to develop into a game-wrecker, but he has every trait you could ask for in an EDGE prospect.
CIN - DL/EDGE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
Long-time followers of the blog & podcast might remember my early takes on Stewart as a 5-star recruit out of high school, as he was (and still is) my all-time top-rated HS prospect. Now, almost four years later, I have him mocked in the top 11 picks and ahead of teammate Nic Scourton. He is the ultimate “My Man™️”, and I’m willing to die on this hill.
MIA - OT Aireontae Ersery, Minnesota
Tua might need to start going by Tau at this rate, honestly (real ones know). If he’s still clear to play by next season, having a new anchor on the offensive line should at least help a little.
IND - CB Benjamin Morrison, ND
A dream scenario for the Colts would be landing Will Johnson, but I don’t expect him to fall outside the top 10. Morrison’s good, though, and would be CB1 in not too long.
DAL - RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
The potential draft placement of Ashton Jeanty might become one of the more hotly-debated topics come April, but at the moment he’s a mid-teens guy for me. The Cowboys might pick higher, however, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they take an early swing on him.
TB - EDGE James Pearce Jr., Tennessee
Man, Malaki Starks would be so fun alongside Antoine Winfield and Tykee Smith in that secondary. Still kicking myself for not making it happen, but James Pearce could have the highest ceiling of any pass-rusher in the draft, and having a potential #1 join that EDGE room could send the Bucs into Super Bowl territory.
LAR - QB Jalen Milroe, Alabama
Like with Shedeur, taking Milroe in the top half of round 1 is a bit rich for my liking. But if any team was to take a swing at Milroe’s electrifying athleticism and anti-naysayer mentality, I’d want it to be Sean McVay’s Rams.
SF - DL Kenneth Grant, Michigan
Shemar Stewart would’ve been my pick for the Niners in a heartbeat if he were still here. Kenneth Grant is a fine consolation prize, and should still be a fearsome addition to what has been a lackluster defensive front in 2024.
ARI - DL Derrick Harmon, Oregon
The Cardinals have heavily out-performed their talent level defensively thanks to HC Jonathan Gannon’s genius, but adding a dominant presence up front in Harmon could elevate the entire unit significantly and prove to be the steal of the draft.
ATL - WR Luther Burden III, Missouri
Stop acting like Atlanta’s ever gonna learn to do otherwise; they’ve gone so far at this point that it’s pointless to turn back now. Michael Penix will have no excuse when Kirk Cousins inevitably tears his other Achilles and is forced to retire in week 3 of next season.
SEA - OT Cameron Williams, Texas
I really wanted this to be Nic Scourton, but I couldn’t justify passing on a tackle at this spot. Cam Williams should be the long-term placeholder on the right side opposite blossoming blindside blocker Charles Cross.
WAS - EDGE Nic Scourton, Texas A&M
Scourton could be the next Myles Garrett, as both are powerful, 6’4”, ~280 lb. defensive ends from Texas A&M expected to go to in the first round of the NFL draft. The similarities end there almost completely, but HC Dan Quinn could help change that.
HOU - DB Malaki Starks, Georgia
According to Google, Houston Texans head coach DeMeco Ryans was born July 28, 1984. In this scenario, to celebrate his 41st birthday a few months early, the rest of the NFL gifts him one of the top 5 players on my overall big board (coming soon) to help fill one of the biggest weaknesses this team has faced this year.
DEN - WR Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State
Pairing Bo Nix’s lightning-quick release with the top slot weapon in the class in Egbuka could lead to one of the lowest average time-to-throw marks in NFL history.
LAC - TE Colston Loveland, Michigan
If Harbaugh can’t land one of his defensive guys from UM in the first round, I can almost guarantee he’ll bring in the top offensive guy from his old team in Loveland, giving QB Justin Herbert a first-round passing option that won’t play like he’s trying to prove he was overdrafted.
BAL - OL Jonah Savaiinaea, Arizona
The Ravens know what they’re looking for on the offensive line: massive, powerful people-movers like Savaiinaea that can give Derrick Henry (or whoever their next lead back is) and Lamar Jackson plenty of room to do what they do best: run wild on opposing defenses.
PIT - DL Walter Nolen, Mississippi
The Steelers are a more complete team than most realize, but can still very much look to add some key pieces this offseason on both sides of the ball. Walter Nolen is an incredibly talented prospect that could become one of the better interior defenders in the league over time, and should instantly add even more teeth to arguably the toughest front in the world.
GB - DL/EDGE L.T. Overton, Alabama
To avoid the confusion of throwing another “Walker” in the Packers’ front seven, I’m sending a versatile big-bodied defensive end that can rush effectively from almost any alignment to Green Bay, which hasn’t happened before and should be much less confusing.
MIN - DL Deone Walker, Kentucky
Although they are not the same player in a handful of ways, Deone Walker reminds me a good amount of Jerry Tillery as a prospect: a tall, long interior defender with unnatural athleticism for his size that struggles with pad level and needs to learn how to use his gifts to his advantage in both phases of the game. With Tillery already in Minnesota, the similar yet complementary duo could work together to unlock some insane potential.
PHI - EDGE/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
This is about as perfect of a match as possible, as the Eagles take yet another dynamic and versatile defender out of Georgia. I could definitely see the Eagles moving up to make this happen if necessary.
BUF - DL Tyleik Williams, Ohio State
Had to get Tyleik in here somehow. Bills could use a young space-eater next to Ed Oliver, and Williams is a dawg.
KC - TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
Warren’s been one of my favorite players to watch this season in college football, and pairing him with Mahomes should be a much smoother transition from the aging Travis Kelce than most would think.
DET - EDGE J.T. Tuimoloau, Ohio State
I would absolutely consider Shavon Revel Jr. out of East Carolina if I were Campbell & Co. here, but Tuimoloau just seems like such a perfect fit for the kneecap-biting culture in Detroit and could be dominant opposite Aidan Hutchinson for years.